5/17/15

Cockney Rebel - The Human Menagerie - The Raw Version (1973)



















A re-up by request of this very interesting document that shows how Human Menagerie could have been if Andrew Powell had not been involved. Not bad (everything this version of the band touched was gold) but not the great achievement the album would be. Catch it here and singalong "Death Trip" and "Sebastian" tonight.

This is an unexpected surprise to hear this great album that is The Human Menagerie in its demo raw version. What's extraordinary is that the songs (not in the final order, an order that seems to have been wished by the band judging by the notes on the tape boxes, a rather bad order actually, with desequilibrated sides, a first one full of sad and slow tempo songs, and a second full of rocker) gain a contempory dimension when they lose the grandeur the wonderful orchestration of Andrew Powell gave them. On some songs, I have the impression to listen to the incunabulum of Felt/Denim or some bands from the Cherry Red label in the eighties. Moreover, there's a trad. English folk flavour in the songs due to the acoustic guitar and violin duo (don't forget the superior beat of Stuart Elliott, one of my all-time fave drummer). These versions were unburied on the 4-CD boxset released this autumn and I can only encourage you to buy it, first because neither an MP3 will provide the quality of a CD or vinyl, and second because there is much more to discover on this boxset. I added "Judy Teen" on the album although it was actually not intended to be on it, but I think it would have been too cruel to deprive the visitor of this unreleased song that was recorded during the same sessions (I suppose, since the dates of these demo sessions are not written on the liner notes, whereas the date of the "Judy Teen" one, March 1973, is). Last, I often wonder how critics can be so blind and deaf on Cockney Rebel case, since the birth of the band until today. For example in Uncut, although the boxset received a 8/10, the condescension, the disregard for the band is shocking. Why always cite Dylan, Bowie, Lou Reed and Roxy Music? Of course they were influences, but what is the fuck when the result was so great and so singular (singular band as the title of the song). Who noticed the folk influence? The Felt legacy? And Ray Davies, who was more an influence to my ears that all the supposed ones cited. No, they are only repeating again and again that the band was plagiarists of the 4 aboves. Even these influences were influenced (just listen how Dylan was a Woody Guthrie imitator in his youth) but propose something entirely new. To compare the metaphysical and symphonic "Death Trip" to the drug-focused and rock "Heroin" is a total nonsense but Jim Wirth from Uncut did it. You'll read more interesting things on the band here althought I don't agree with all. But let's forget it and enjoy here this piece of genius here. I created a cover sleeve cos' I like that. Not fantastic but honest I think.




12 comments:

Private Beach said...

I like the way you named your download file "Human Men". It suggests that somewhere there are inhuman men walking around.

dkelvin said...

Not intentional but true that there are much more inhuman men than human ones on this damned planet to my eyes. Thx for noticing.dk

Anonymous said...

Thank you for sharing this indeed interesting LP showing the work in progress of the menagerie.

Derek from Paris

deruf said...

This was one of the first LPs I ever called my own and it has been one of my favorites ever since. Samples sound really different from what I know. Great. Thanks a lot!

deruf, Munich

Anonymous said...

Why not share the whole box? I can´t afford it anyway. Thanks for a wonderful blog. You have a goooood taste. Cheers! Manny

rough mix said...

This LP is part of my musical DNA and it was thanks to you

Anonymous said...

Thankyou for this and lots more
I've grabbed,as said above I
admire your taste.Top Blog

john smith said...

I like your blog Secret Photography Techniques is there to improve photography techniques and Ipad Training Course to know how to use ipad.

Anonymous said...

Awful great, this blog, thank you for the music! One small problem though, some files are still linked to Rapidshare, that has stopped it's services. I would certainly appreciate a re-upload to M of the raw version of The Human Menagerie by SH & CR. Thanx!

Anonymous said...

Thanx for the re-up, brother; that's what they call instant delivery!! It's playing just now, and I fully agree with you: this version is absolutely superior to the official one. This being said: have you ever heard registrations of Harley's solo performances in the late 1990's? Cockney Rebel music stripped to the bone; I upped this one to M for you; feel free to share it on this blog: https://mega.co.nz/#!ogdlUa4I!a8KBvxp32zgqS2rhm1jChCqtCCl46qHZ60BTmtU4tOA

dkelvin said...

Thx for the comment but you misquote me. I didn't write that the raw version was superior to the official one. For me, the orchestral arrangement were an absolute success and were part of the impact this album had on me. And after this version of the band, I think Steve Harley didn't reach these standards again although I like most of his later stuff.
dk

Anonymous said...

Thank you for this re-up. Mostly interesting for all the visitors coming in. I saw Steve Harley in concert some weeks ago in Belgium and he still delivers the shivers inside, even on his more recent work as Bleeding Heart. Amazing artist he is !!!

Derek from Paris